To my mind Moffat's female characters are differently bad from RTD's, but not in a readily comparable way; Moffat's being all Puzzles To Be Solved irks the hell out of me but no more than RTD's romance focus did.

I would like to see a female Doctor but I don't trust the current team not to screw that up really badly. And I wish there'd be more interesting choices in companion dynamics - a Gene Hunt or a Margaret Rutherford character, for example.